Premium Bookkeeping

Handling Salary and Wage Overpayments: Best Practices and Guidelines

Administering salary overpayments is a complex challenge in payroll management. Distinguishing between payroll errors and repayments of wages is essential for ensuring compliance and maintaining fairness.

These guidelines aid organizations in identifying these issues and adhering to best practices for statutory deductions and year-end reporting.

Types of Overpayments

Overpayments generally fall into two categories:

  1. Payroll Errors: These mistakes arise from administrative or clerical oversights, including incorrect entries of pay rates or hours, miscalculations of vacation pay, or compensation for periods of unpaid leave.
  2. Repayments of Wages: This category covers situations where payments are made to employees who have not met their contractual obligations. Examples include:|
    1. Unearned Benefits: Such as vacation pay received in advance or signing bonuses provided without fulfilling the required tenure.
    2. Top-Up Benefits: Where an employee receives additional benefits but fails to return to work for the agreed period.
    3. Salary Continuance Overlaps: Where an employee continues to receive their salary through employer arrangements but also starts receiving benefits from sources like wage-loss replacement plans, workers’ compensation, or jury duty payments.

Advising the Employee of the Payroll Error

  • When a payroll error leading to an overpayment is identified, it's crucial to notify the affected employee in writing as soon as possible. For substantial overpayments or if the employee is no longer associated with the organization, consider sending the notice by registered mail to ensure it is received and to provide a record of the communication.
  • If employment or labour standards prevent automatic deduction of the overpayment from the employee's subsequent paychecks, the notification should also detail a proposed repayment schedule. Alternatively, it should instruct the employee or former employee to contact the payroll department to arrange a suitable repayment plan. This approach not only ensures compliance with various regulations but also maintains a clear and professional relationship with current or former employees.

Administrative Procedures

Identifying Overpayments:

  • Determine if the overpayment is a payroll error or a repayment of wages.
  • Ensure compliance with statutory deductions and year-end reporting.

Recovering Overpayments:

  • Same-Year Recovery: Employees repay the net amount, and employers adjust statutory deductions and year-to-date earnings.
  • Different Year Recovery: If overpayments are discovered in a different tax year, employees may need to repay the gross amount. Employers must amend the year-end tax slips accordingly.

Repayment Methods

Employees can repay overpayments through:

  • Personal cheque
  • Pre-authorized debit
  • Deductions from future wages, with written consent

Compliance and Reporting

Statutory Deductions:

  • Adjustments must be made to reduce both overpaid income and statutory deductions.
  • Employers can request refunds for overpaid contributions and premiums from CRA. For detailed information on refund procedures, visit the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) guidelines on overpayments.

Year-End Reporting include:

  • Overpayments should be excluded from T4 slips unless the employee agrees to repay but fails to do so, in which case they are reported as employment income. The CRA's year-end reporting guidelines provide more details on this process.

Preventive Measures

To prevent overpayments:

  • Review manually-keyed payroll changes.
  • Implement checklists for employees on leave or terminated.
  • Verify payroll entries with a second person.
  • Utilize automated time and attendance systems.


Navigating salary and wage overpayments requires meticulous attention to detail and a commitment to regulatory compliance. By adhering to these best practices, organizations can ensure compliance and fairness, thereby minimizing the impact of overpayments on employers and employees.

Stay updated and compliant by regularly consulting resources like the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) website for the latest information and updates.

At Plus Advisors, we are dedicated to providing our clients with the support and resources necessary to navigate the complexities of payroll management effectively. Contact us today to learn more about how we can help you optimize your payroll processes and ensure compliance.

Get started with Plus Advisors

We don't just provide tailored solutions and expertise, we're committed to helping your business thrive. Unlock the full profit potential of your business with Plus Advisors.

Get Started